Best Italian Restaurants in Newark
Curated guide featuring 7 outstanding restaurants, all rated 4.5+ stars
Newark's Italian dining scene is a testament to the city's rich cultural heritage, where generations of Italian-American families have transformed neighborhood corners into culinary destinations that rival anything you'll find across the Hudson. This isn't about flashy presentations or trendy fusion – it's about time-honored recipes passed down through families, handmade pasta that tastes like nonna's kitchen, and red sauce so perfect it'll make you question every jarred marinara you've ever bought. The authenticity here runs deep, from third-generation pizzaiolos who still hand-toss their dough to trattorias where the owner's mother might emerge from the kitchen to check on your meal.
This guide showcases 10 exceptional Italian restaurants that have earned their stellar reputations one satisfied customer at a time, with an impressive collective average of 4.6 stars. From the legendary Del Porto with nearly 5,000 glowing reviews to intimate family-run gems tucked away in residential neighborhoods, each spot offers something special – whether it's the city's best chicken parmigiana, perfectly charred brick-oven pizza, or homemade gnocchi that melts in your mouth. These aren't just restaurants; they're Newark institutions where great food and warm hospitality create memories that'll have you planning your return visit before you've even finished dessert.
Featured Restaurants
DEL PORTO ITALIAN RESTAURANT
Del Porto Italian Restaurant has earned an impressive 4.9-star rating from over 3,000 diners, making it a standout gem in Elizabeth that consistently delivers exceptional Italian cuisine and warm hospitality. Travelers rave about the authentic flavors and welcoming atmosphere that keeps locals and visitors returning time and again. With its stellar reputation and moderate pricing, it's wise to make reservations, especially on weekends when this beloved neighborhood favorite tends to fill up quickly.
Taverna Newark
Taverna Newark has earned its stellar reputation among locals and visitors alike, serving up a diverse menu that caters to every palate in a welcoming atmosphere on Main Street. With over 1,000 glowing reviews and a 4.5-star rating, diners consistently rave about the quality food and friendly service that keeps them coming back. Reserve ahead for weekend dinners, as this popular spot tends to fill up quickly with both university crowds and families.
Belmont Tavern
This beloved neighborhood gem on Bloomfield Ave has earned a stellar reputation among locals and visitors alike, serving up diverse comfort foods in a welcoming tavern atmosphere that feels like your favorite local hangout. With nearly 800 glowing reviews and a 4.6-star rating, diners consistently praise the generous portions, friendly service, and reliably satisfying meals that keep them coming back. Arrive early on weekends to snag a table, as this popular spot tends to fill up quickly with regulars who know a good thing when they taste it.
La Fiamma
La Fiamma has earned its stellar 4.7-star reputation among over 600 reviewers with its welcoming bar atmosphere and consistently satisfying food that keeps both locals and visitors coming back. The high rating suggests this Harrison spot delivers on quality and service, making it a reliable choice for travelers seeking an authentic neighborhood experience. Arrive early for the best seating options, as popular local gems like this tend to fill up quickly during peak dining hours.
Luigino's Parmigiana
Luigino's Parmigiana has earned a devoted following in Montclair with its impressive 4.7-star rating from over 400 diners who consistently praise the authentic flavors and welcoming atmosphere. This neighborhood gem serves up satisfying Italian-American classics that keep locals and visitors returning for more, creating the kind of bustling, friendly vibe that makes any meal feel special. With such consistently high ratings, it's worth calling ahead or arriving early during peak dinner hours to secure your table at this popular spot.
BOSCHETTO
Boschetto on Grove Street has earned a devoted following with its impressive 4.7-star rating from hundreds of diners who consistently praise the quality and variety of its diverse menu offerings. This welcoming Montclair gem delivers the kind of reliable, satisfying dining experience that keeps both locals and visitors coming back for more. With its strong reputation and moderate pricing, it's wise to make reservations, especially during weekend dinner hours when this popular spot tends to fill up quickly.
Luigi's Italian Tradition
Luigi's Italian Tradition brings authentic Italian flavors to Newark's Bloomfield Avenue, creating a warm, family-friendly atmosphere that feels like dining at a beloved neighborhood gem. With an impressive 4.5-star rating from nearly 300 reviews, travelers consistently praise the generous portions, friendly service, and traditional recipes that deliver genuine Italian comfort food. Visit during weeknight hours for a more relaxed experience, and don't hesitate to ask your server about daily specials that showcase the kitchen's best seasonal offerings.
Culinary Experiences in Newark
Discover food tours, cooking classes, and unique dining experiences